Skip to content
GERICLINICS

Flashcards · Module 10

⚖️ Ethics, Capacity & End-of-Life Care

4 of 4 cards published · read by the site’s author on 17 November 2026

The 4 Components of Decision-Making Capacity

Needs clinical review

The MacCAT-CR Framework (Easy Mnemonic: "UARE"):

  1. Understanding — Can they understand the diagnosis, treatment options, risks, and benefits?

  2. Appreciation — Can they see how it applies to their own situation?

  3. Reasoning — Can they weigh the options against their own values?

  4. Expressing a choice — Can they clearly and consistently state their decision?

Critical Rules:

  • Capacity is decision-specific (may have capacity for some decisions but not others)

  • Capacity is time-specific (may fluctuate — check again later)

  • Having dementia does NOT automatically mean lacking capacity

  • A patient may lack capacity for complex surgery consent but retain capacity to appoint a surrogate

Exam Trap: A patient who makes a decision you disagree with is NOT necessarily lacking capacity. The right to make an "unwise" decision is legally protected — as long as the 4 criteria above are met.
Sources checked (6) · 14 November 2026

PEG Tubes in Advanced Dementia: What does the evidence actually show?

Needs clinical review

The Evidence Is Clear (AGS, BGA, AAN Consensus):

OutcomeDoes PEG Help?
Prolong survival?❌ NO
Prevent aspiration pneumonia?❌ NO (aspiration of oral secretions continues)
Heal pressure ulcers?❌ NO
Improve quality of life?❌ NO
Cause harm?✅ YES — increased agitation, restraint use, tube infections, hospital transfers

The Standard of Care:

Careful hand feeding ("comfort feeding") is the evidence-based approach for dysphagia in end-stage dementia.

One-Liner: PEG tubes in advanced dementia do NOT prolong life, do NOT prevent aspiration, and cause measurable harm. Hand feeding is the standard of care.
Sources checked (1) · 14 November 2026

Low-Dose Morphine for End-of-Life Breathlessness: Is it safe?

Needs clinical review

The Answer: YES — when properly titrated.

How It Works:

  • Blunts the breathing response to CO₂ buildup

  • Relieves the terrifying sensation of air hunger

  • Eases the sensation of breathlessness; it does not treat low oxygen saturation

Starting Dose:

  • Morphine 2.5 mg oral every 4 hours, with extra doses as needed

  • Or subcutaneous morphine (or oxycodone) for patients who can't swallow

  • Aim at comfort, in line with the patient's and family's goals

Manage Constipation Proactively:

Tolerance to opioid-induced constipation does not develop, so plan bowel care.

Exam Trap: Some students worry that morphine will "kill" the patient by suppressing breathing. In a trial of regular low-dose morphine for chronic breathlessness, there were no cases of respiratory depression.
Sources checked (4) · 14 November 2026

What are the REAL survival rates for CPR in frail older adults?

Needs clinical review

Reality vs. Television:

ScenarioSurvival to Hospital Discharge
TV shows~67% (highly unrealistic)
In-hospital arrest, all adults (US registry, 2009)~22% (risk-adjusted)
Nursing home arrest (one Korean study)about 2–4%
Good neurological recoveryabout 1% or less of nursing home arrests

How to Communicate This:

❌ Don't ask: "Do you want us to do everything?"
✅ Do say: "What matters most to you in the time you have? Let me explain what CPR can and cannot do for you."

One-Liner: CPR rarely succeeds after cardiac arrest in a nursing home (about 2–4% survived to discharge in one study; about 1% or less with good brain function). Frame discussions around values and goals, not "doing everything."
Sources checked (5) · 14 November 2026