Flashcards · Module 10
⚖️ Ethics, Capacity & End-of-Life Care
4 of 4 cards published · read by the site’s author on 17 November 2026
The 4 Components of Decision-Making Capacity
Needs clinical review
The MacCAT-CR Framework (Easy Mnemonic: "UARE"):
Understanding — Can they understand the diagnosis, treatment options, risks, and benefits?
Appreciation — Can they see how it applies to their own situation?
Reasoning — Can they weigh the options against their own values?
Expressing a choice — Can they clearly and consistently state their decision?
Critical Rules:
Capacity is decision-specific (may have capacity for some decisions but not others)
Capacity is time-specific (may fluctuate — check again later)
Having dementia does NOT automatically mean lacking capacity
A patient may lack capacity for complex surgery consent but retain capacity to appoint a surrogate
Sources checked (6) · 14 November 2026
- Medical Decision-Making Capacity in Early-Stage Alzheimer Patients: Comparison With Healthy Controls and Benefit of Assistive Information. (2026)
- Improving the Consent Process for Superficial Abscesses Through Pre-printed Consent Forms. (2024)
- American Geriatrics Society position statement: Making medical treatment decisions for unrepresented older adults. (2025)
- Voluntary assisted dying for dementia: international regulatory approaches and practices. (2026)
- Making Medical Treatment Decisions for Unrepresented Patients in the ICU. An Official American Thoracic Society/American Geriatrics Society Policy Statement. (2020)
- Mental capacity assessment in the multi-professional real world: a qualitative study of six areas of uncertainty. (2024)
PEG Tubes in Advanced Dementia: What does the evidence actually show?
Needs clinical review
The Evidence Is Clear (AGS, BGA, AAN Consensus):
| Outcome | Does PEG Help? |
|---|---|
| Prolong survival? | ❌ NO |
| Prevent aspiration pneumonia? | ❌ NO (aspiration of oral secretions continues) |
| Heal pressure ulcers? | ❌ NO |
| Improve quality of life? | ❌ NO |
| Cause harm? | ✅ YES — increased agitation, restraint use, tube infections, hospital transfers |
The Standard of Care:
Careful hand feeding ("comfort feeding") is the evidence-based approach for dysphagia in end-stage dementia.
Sources checked (1) · 14 November 2026
Low-Dose Morphine for End-of-Life Breathlessness: Is it safe?
Needs clinical review
The Answer: YES — when properly titrated.
How It Works:
Blunts the breathing response to CO₂ buildup
Relieves the terrifying sensation of air hunger
Eases the sensation of breathlessness; it does not treat low oxygen saturation
Starting Dose:
Morphine 2.5 mg oral every 4 hours, with extra doses as needed
Or subcutaneous morphine (or oxycodone) for patients who can't swallow
Aim at comfort, in line with the patient's and family's goals
Manage Constipation Proactively:
Tolerance to opioid-induced constipation does not develop, so plan bowel care.
Sources checked (4) · 14 November 2026
- Guideline for Medication Management of Distressing Symptoms in Older Patients Receiving End-of-Life Palliative Care. (2026)
- Regular, sustained-release morphine for chronic breathlessness: a multicentre, double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled trial. (2020)
- Using laboratory models to test treatment: morphine reduces dyspnea and hypercapnic ventilatory response. (2011)
- Treating Opioid-Induced Constipation in Older Adults: New Options. (2015)
What are the REAL survival rates for CPR in frail older adults?
Needs clinical review
Reality vs. Television:
| Scenario | Survival to Hospital Discharge |
|---|---|
| TV shows | ~67% (highly unrealistic) |
| In-hospital arrest, all adults (US registry, 2009) | ~22% (risk-adjusted) |
| Nursing home arrest (one Korean study) | about 2–4% |
| Good neurological recovery | about 1% or less of nursing home arrests |
How to Communicate This:
❌ Don't ask: "Do you want us to do everything?"
✅ Do say: "What matters most to you in the time you have? Let me explain what CPR can and cannot do for you."
Sources checked (5) · 14 November 2026
- End-of-life decision-making in very old critically ill patients. (2026)
- Cardiopulmonary resuscitation on television. Miracles and misinformation. (1996)
- Trends in survival after in-hospital cardiac arrest. (2012)
- Prehospital advanced cardiac life support by EMT with a smartphone-based direct medical control for nursing home cardiac arrest. (2018)
- Resuscitation in Oncology: Limits, Ethics, Practice, and Humanity. (2026)