GeriQBank · Paper IV · Q5
Social Security System for Older People in India
- Chapter
- Health Policy, National Programmes & Social Gerontology
- Years asked
- Not recorded in the source
- Frequency
- Set 2× in Paper IV (2009–2025)
As set in the university paper
Describe the social security system for older people in India.
Paper IV · Health Systems, National Programmes, Policy & Social Geriatrics · asked ×2 · 15-mark essay + 7-mark note · see in paper list
Answer framework
- Concept and framework — definition and ILO Convention 102; constitutional basis; the Indian problem; why it matters clinically; the multi-pillar model
- Pillar 0, social assistance — NSAP and its five components; IGNOAPS and its weakness; food security
- Pillars 1 and 2, social insurance — EPFO schemes; the EPS-95 adequacy problem; OPS, NPS and UPS; gratuity and retiree health cover
- Pillar 3, voluntary instruments — Atal Pension Yojana; SCSS and other savings; tax reliefs
- Health social security — PM-JAY, Vay Vandana and NPHCE
- Pillar 4, legal and informal — the family's legal duty and the MWPSC Act; welfare services
- Gaps and critique — fragmentation, inadequacy, exclusion, gender gap, no long-term care, targeting errors; the one-line summary
- Recent updates — Labour Codes; EPS 2026; UPS; ILO coverage; APY and e-Shram; a portable social security identity
An exam answer plan drawn from the detailed answer below. Use it to attempt the question first.
Detailed answer
Pro · free in betaAttempt it firstOutline your answer as a 15-mark essay + 7-mark note before revealing it — definition, causes, evaluation, management and the geriatric angle.Reveal answer
Short revision answer
- Social security protects against distress from lost income; ILO Convention 102 (1952) has nine branches, of which old-age, survivors', invalidity and medical care matter most for older people. Constitution: Article 41 (public assistance in old age), Articles 43 and 47; social security is on the Concurrent List.
- India is "growing old before it grows rich": about 90% of workers are informal, so tax-financed assistance, not contributory insurance, must carry the load. Over 40% of elders are in the poorest quintile and 18.7% have no income at all; older women, especially widows, are poorest.
- Multi-pillar model: 0 assistance (NSAP); 1 social insurance (EPS, OPS/UPS); 2 defined contribution (NPS); 3 voluntary (APY, SCSS, PMVVY); 4 informal — the family, still dominant in India.
- Pillar 0: NSAP (1995, Rural Development) — IGNOAPS, IGNWPS, IGNDPS, NFBS and Annapurna (10 kg grain). IGNOAPS pays ₹200/month (60+) and ₹500 (80+) to BPL elders, unrevised for over a decade despite NPOP's promise; States top it up. Food: NFSA 2013, PDS and Antyodaya.
- Pillars 1–2: EPF (12% + 12%); EPS-95 (8.33% of the employer share; pension after 10 years' service and age 58; minimum ₹1,000/month since 2014 against demands for ₹7,500); OPS (50% of last pay, recruited before 2004); NPS (defined contribution from 1 January 2004, regulated by PFRDA); UPS from 1 April 2025; gratuity (15 days' wages per year); CGHS and ECHS.
- Pillar 3: Atal Pension Yojana (2015; ages 18–40, non-taxpayers; guaranteed ₹1,000–₹5,000/month after 60; spouse continues). SCSS (8.2%, maximum ₹30 lakh), PMVVY, reverse mortgage, Post Office MIS. Tax reliefs: ₹3 lakh/₹5 lakh exemptions, 80TTB ₹50,000, 80D, 80DDB.
- Health: PM-JAY ₹5 lakh/family/year; Ayushman Vay Vandana (October 2024) covers all citizens 70+ regardless of income; NPHCE delivers care from AAM-HWC to Regional Geriatric Centres. Legal: Section 125 CrPC (now 144 BNSS), the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act 1956 and the MWPSC Act 2007 (tribunals, ₹10,000/month cap, 90 days, abandonment punishable, property transfer voidable); AVYAY and Elderline 14567.
- Critique: fragmented across five ministries; inadequate (₹200 IGNOAPS, ₹1,000 EPS); excludes informal workers, unpaid women and migrants; a gender gap; no long-term care financing; BPL targeting errors. Summary: a narrow contributory core, a thin assistance floor, a voluntary middle — and the family still carries most of the burden.
- Updates: the four Labour Codes took effect on 21 November 2025 — the Code on Social Security 2020 merges nine laws and covers gig and platform workers for the first time (Sections 113 and 114; aggregators pay 1–2% of turnover). EPS 2026 replaced EPS-95 (minimum still ₹1,000; claims settled within 20 days or 12% interest). UPS: 50% of the last 12 months' basic pay after 25 years, minimum ₹10,000, family pension 60%; uptake is low (4.3%).
- ILO 2024–26: India's cash-benefit coverage doubled from 24.4% (2021) to 48.8% (2024), about 65% including in-kind. APY passed 9 crore enrolments and e-Shram 30.68 crore registrations. Direction: a Universal Social Security Account (draft Shram Shakti Niti 2025) and NITI Aayog's call for a base interest rate on senior-citizen deposits.
Condensed by GeriClinics from the detailed answer below, with no new facts added.
SOURCE STATEMENT
Pathy’s 6th edition does NOT describe the Indian social security system. Chapter 4 covers only the general problem of old-age poverty and US Social Security data; Essentials Ch. 15 covers US Medicare, Medicaid, Title XX and the Older Americans Act.
All India-specific content is from Government of India, ILO and PFRDA sources. Textbook concepts are attributed where used.
A. Concept and Framework
Definition. Social security is the protection society provides against economic and social distress caused by loss or reduction of income. The ILO Social Security (Minimum Standards) Convention, 1952 (No. 102) recognises nine branches, of which old-age benefit, survivors’ benefit, invalidity benefit and medical care are relevant to the elderly.
Constitutional basis (must quote). Article 41 — the State shall make effective provision for securing the right to public assistance in old age, sickness and disablement; Article 43 — living wage and conditions ensuring a decent standard of life; Article 47 — raising nutrition and standard of living and improving public health. Social security is in the Concurrent List (Entry 23).
The Indian problem in one line: India is “growing old before it grows rich,” and around 90% of the workforce is in the unorganised sector with no employer-linked pension. Social security must therefore be delivered mainly through tax-financed social assistance, not contributory insurance.
Why this matters clinically. The India Ageing Report 2023 found over 40% of India’s elderly in the poorest wealth quintile and 18.7% with no income at all, with a rising predominance of widowed, highly dependent very old women. Pathy’s makes the same point globally: older women, particularly those who did not marry, are at the highest risk of poverty, being least likely to qualify for national or occupational pensions, and longer life expectancy means women are at increased risk of spending down their savings.
Useful classification (World Bank multi-pillar model) — use this to structure your answer: Pillar 0 — Social assistance: non-contributory, tax-funded, means-tested (NSAP/IGNOAPS) Pillar 1 — Social insurance: mandatory, contributory, formal sector (EPS-95, OPS/UPS)
Pillar 2 — Mandatory defined-contribution: NPS
Pillar 3 — Voluntary savings: APY, SCSS, PMVVY, insurance Pillar 4 — Informal: family support, co-residence, health care, housing — still the dominant pillar in India B. Pillar 0 — Social Assistance (for the poor elderly)
National Social Assistance Programme (NSAP), 1995 — Ministry of Rural Development, the direct fulfilment of Article 41. Five components: IGNOAPS (old age), IGNWPS (widow, 40–79 years), IGNDPS (disability), NFBS (lump sum on death of breadwinner), and Annapurna (10 kg free foodgrain per month to destitute elderly not covered by IGNOAPS).
IGNOAPS — the flagship, and its biggest weakness. Central assistance is ₹200 per month above 60 and ₹500 per month above 80 for BPL senior citizens; States add top-ups (Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Delhi pay considerably more). Exam point: the central share has not been revised in over a decade, despite NPOP 1999 explicitly promising that “the rate of monthly pension will need to be revised at intervals so that inflation does not deflate its real purchasing power.”
Food and in-kind security: National Food Security Act 2013 (subsidised grain through PDS), Antyodaya Anna Yojana, and community kitchens/Amma canteens. NPOP 1999 directed that the PDS should reach all persons aged 60+ below the poverty line.
C. Pillars 1 & 2 — Social Insurance for the Organised Sector
EPFO schemes (private/organised sector): EPF (12% employee + 12% employer); EPS-95, funded by 8.33% of the employer’s share, pension after 10 years of service and age 58 (early pension from 50 at a reduced rate), formula = (Pensionable Salary × Pensionable Service) ÷ 70; EDLI (deposit-linked insurance); and ESI (medical care and cash benefits for insured workers).
The EPS-95 adequacy problem (guaranteed discussion point). The minimum EPS pension has remained ₹1,000 per month since 1 September 2014, while unions and pensioners’ associations demand ₹7,500. A proposal to raise the pensionable wage ceiling from ₹15,000 to ₹25,000 — benefiting over 6.5 crore employees — is under review, but no revision has been notified.
Government employees — three generations of schemes: Old Pension Scheme (OPS) — defined benefit, 50% of last drawn pay, for those recruited before 1 January 2004; National Pension System (NPS) — defined contribution, market-linked, mandatory for those joining on or after 1 January 2004, regulated by PFRDA; and Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) — from 1 April 2025.
Other formal-sector entitlements: Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (15 days’ wages per year of service); commutation of pension; leave encashment; and contributory health cover for retirees — CGHS, ECHS, Railway and state government health schemes.
D. Pillar 3 — Voluntary and Market-Based Instruments
Atal Pension Yojana (APY) — the main instrument for the unorganised sector. Launched 9 May 2015, administered by PFRDA, voluntary and contributory, open to citizens aged 18–40 who are not income-tax payers, guaranteeing a fixed monthly pension of ₹1,000 to ₹5,000 after age 60, the same pension to the spouse after death, and return of the accumulated corpus to the nominee after both die.
Savings and annuity products: SCSS — 8.2% p.a. paid quarterly, age 60+ (55+ VRS, 50+ defence), maximum ₹30 lakh, tenure 5 years extendable by 3, with 80C deduction and TDS only above ₹1 lakh interest. Also PMVVY, NPS “All Citizen” model, Reverse Mortgage Loan, and Post Office Monthly Income Scheme.
Tax expenditure as social security: higher basic exemption of ₹3 lakh (60–79) and ₹5 lakh (80+) under the old regime; Section 80TTB — ₹50,000 deduction on interest income; no advance tax if there is no business income (Section 207); plus Section 80D and Section 80DDB.
E. Health Social Security
Health protection is the fastest-moving pillar. AB PM-JAY gives ₹5 lakh per family per year; the Ayushman Vay Vandana Card (October 2024) extends ₹5 lakh cover to all citizens aged 70+ irrespective of income, with an additional top-up for PM-JAY families. Service delivery is through NPHCE (AAM-HWC → PHC → CHC → District Hospital → Regional Geriatric Centre). This closes the gap NPOP 1999 identified when it said health insurance for the elderly “will be given high priority.”
F. Pillar 4 — Legal and Informal Social Security
The family is legally the first line of social security. Section 125 CrPC (now Section 144 BNSS) and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 create a duty to maintain parents. The MWPSC Act, 2007 operationalises this through Maintenance Tribunals (cap ₹10,000/month, disposal within 90 days), makes abandonment a punishable offence, and allows transfer of property to be declared void if the transferee fails to provide basic amenities.
Welfare services as social security: AVYAY (IPSrC old-age homes, RVY free assistive devices for BPL/income ≤ ₹15,000 per month, SCOPE, SAGE), Elderline 14567, and the Senior Citizens’ Welfare Fund.
G. Coverage, Gaps and Critique (examiners reward critique)
Structural weaknesses of the Indian system: Fragmentation — spread across MoSJE, MoRD, MoHFW, Labour and Finance, with no single accountable authority Inadequacy — IGNOAPS at ₹200/month and EPS-95 at ₹1,000/month are far below any subsistence line Exclusion — the informal workforce, unpaid women workers, agricultural labourers and migrants fall outside contributory schemes Gendered gap — ILO data show older women are less likely to receive a contributory pension than men; NPOP 1999 warned of “triple neglect and discrimination on account of gender, widowhood and age” No long-term care financing — India has no statutory LTC or disability-linked care allowance for frail elders Targeting errors — BPL identification excludes many genuinely poor elderly
The one-line summary for the exam: India’s old-age social security is a narrow contributory core for the organised minority, a thin tax-financed assistance floor for the poorest, and a large voluntary/market segment in between — with the family still carrying most of the burden. The 2024–2026 reforms (Labour Codes, UPS, Vay Vandana Card) are the first serious attempt to widen that base. Summary Table — The Indian Old-Age Social Security Architecture Pillar Scheme Ministry / Regulator Benefit Who is covered 0 — Assistance IGNOAPS (NSAP) Rural Development ₹200/month (60–79), ₹500/month BPL elderly (80+) Annapurna, NFSA/PDS Rural Dev / Food 10 kg grain/month; subsidised Destitute / priority grain households 1 — Insurance EPS-95 → EPS 2026 Labour / EPFO Pension after 10 yrs, age 58; min Organised private sector ₹1,000/month OPS Finance 50% of last drawn pay Govt employees pre-2004 2 — Defined NPS PFRDA Market-linked corpus + annuity Govt post-2004, corporates, contribution all citizens UPS (from 1 Apr 2025) Finance / PFRDA 50% of last 12 months’ average Central govt employees basic pay; min ₹10,000/month under NPS 3 — Voluntary APY PFRDA ₹1,000–₹5,000/month guaranteed Unorganised workers 18–40 SCSS, PMVVY, Reverse Finance / LIC / Banks 8.2% quarterly; annuity; home Any senior citizen with Mortgage equity income assets Health PM-JAY + Vay Vandana MoHFW / NHA ₹5 lakh/year; universal for 70+ Poor + all citizens aged 70+ Card CGHS / ECHS / ESI Various Contributory medical care Government / defence / insured workers 4 — Informal & MWPSC Act 2007, Sec Law & Justice Legally enforceable maintenance All senior citizens legal 144 BNSS AVYAY, Elderline 14567 MoSJE Shelter, devices, helpline Indigent / BPL elderly LATEST UPDATES (2023–PRESENT)
The Four Labour Codes came into force on 21 November 2025 — the biggest reform in decades. The Government notified the Code on Wages 2019, Industrial Relations Code 2020, Code on Social Security 2020 and OSH Code 2020, rationalising 29 existing central labour laws. The Code on Social Security, 2020 consolidates NINE existing social security laws into a single framework covering organised, unorganised, gig and platform workers, extending provident fund, gratuity, life and disability insurance, health and maternity benefits. For the first time in India, social security benefits have been extended to unorganised, gig and platform workers under Sections 113 and 114. Aggregators must contribute 1–2% of turnover (capped) to a dedicated Social Security Fund; draft central rules notified 30 December 2025 propose eligibility after 90 days with one aggregator or 120 days across multiple aggregators in a financial year, with Aadhaar-linked registration through e-Shram ensuring portability.
Employees’ Pension Scheme (EPS), 2026 has replaced EPS-95. Notified under the Social Security Code 2020 — the biggest legal overhaul of the scheme in more than three decades, affecting over 30 crore EPFO subscribers. Core features retained: minimum pension remains ₹1,000 per month, formula unchanged. Key procedural reform: EPFO must settle pension claims within 20 days, failing which 12% annual interest is payable. Exam framing: the legal architecture has modernised, but the benefit level has not.
Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) — effective 1 April 2025. Provides an assured pension of 50% of the average basic pay of the last 12 months for a minimum qualifying service of 25 years (proportionate down to 10 years); assured family pension at 60%; assured minimum pension of ₹10,000 per month after at least 10 years; inflation indexation with Dearness Relief based on AICPI-IW; and a lump sum of one-tenth of monthly emoluments for every completed six months of service, in addition to gratuity. About 23 lakh central government employees are eligible. Contributions: employee 10% of Basic + DA, matching government 10%, plus an additional ~8.5% into a pool corpus. Uptake has been low — 118,195 employees (4.3% of 2.76 million NPS subscribers) opted in as of July 2025, and a one-time switch back to NPS has been allowed.
India’s social protection coverage has doubled — ILO World Social Protection Report 2024–26. Coverage by at least one social protection cash benefit rose from 24.4% (2021) to 48.8% (2024); per MoLE, nearly 920 million people (65% of the population) are covered in cash or in kind. India’s progress contributed a 5% increase in global social protection coverage. Globally the world has crossed the halfway mark for the first time, with 52.4% covered, and countries spend on average 12.9% of GDP on social protection excluding healthcare.
Scale-up of unorganised-sector instruments. Atal Pension Yojana crossed 9 crore gross enrolments as of 21 April 2026, with over 1.35 crore new subscribers in FY26 — the highest annual enrolment since launch; in FY 2024-25, 55% of new APY enrolments were women. The e-Shram portal (launched 26 August 2021) had over 30.68 crore registrations by March 2025, of which 53.68% were women.
Direction of travel — a single portable social security identity. The draft Shram Shakti Niti, 2025 proposes a Universal Social Security Account merging EPFO, ESIC, e-Shram and PM-JAY into one portable identity. India also launched a Social Protection Data Pooling Exercise on 19 March 2025, Phase 1 covering 10 states including Tamil Nadu and processing over 200 crore welfare records. NITI Aayog (2024) recommends a regulatory base interest rate on senior-citizen deposits, noting most seniors depend on savings income which variable rates can push below sustenance level.
CURRENT PRACTICE UPDATE
Element Position as classically taught Position in 2026 Statutory framework Nine separate Acts (EPF 1952, ESI 1948, All consolidated into the Code on Social Security, Gratuity 1972, Maternity Benefit 1961, etc.) 2020, in force from 21 November 2025 EPS EPS-95 EPS 2026 notified under the Code; minimum pension still ₹1,000/month; 20-day claim settlement with 12% penal interest Government pension OPS (pre-2004) vs NPS (post-2004) Third option — UPS from 1 April 2025: 50% assured, min ₹10,000/month, family pension 60%, AICPI-IW indexed Gig and platform workers Entirely outside social security Legally recognised for the first time; aggregator contribution of 1–2% of turnover to a Social Security Fund Coverage Often quoted as “only ~10–12% of workforce 48.8% covered by at least one cash benefit (ILO covered” 2024); ~65% including in-kind Health protection Means-tested or employment-linked only Universal, age-based ₹5 lakh cover for all 70+ since October 2024 IGNOAPS ₹200 / ₹500 per month central share Unchanged — the clearest failure of indexation in the system Long-term care Not addressed Still no statutory LTC financing — flagged by NITI Aayog and the UN Decade Identity / portability Scheme-wise, non-portable Moving toward a Universal Social Security Account (draft Shram Shakti Niti 2025)
EXAMINER’S TIP — VERBATIM MARK-EARNING LINES
“India is growing old before it grows rich — with roughly 90% of the workforce informal, contributory insurance can never be the primary instrument.”
“I would classify Indian old-age social security using the World Bank multi-pillar model: Pillar 0 assistance, Pillar 1 insurance, Pillar 2 defined contribution, Pillar 3 voluntary and Pillar 4 informal — in India, Pillar 4, the family, remains dominant.”
“The Code on Social Security 2020, in force since 21 November 2025, extends social security to gig and platform workers for the first time under Sections 113 and 114.”
“India’s social protection coverage doubled from 24.4% in 2021 to 48.8% in 2024, contributing a 5% rise in global coverage.”
“The legal architecture has modernised, but the benefit levels have not: IGNOAPS at ₹200 and EPS at ₹1,000 a month remain far below any subsistence line.”
EXTRA POINTS TO REMEMBER
ILO Convention 102 (1952) — nine branches of social security.
Key dates: NSAP 1995 • EPS 1995 • NPS 1 Jan 2004 • APY 9 May 2015 • e-Shram 26 Aug 2021 • UPS 1 Apr 2025 • Labour Codes 21 Nov 2025.
EPS formula: (Pensionable Salary × Pensionable Service) ÷ 70; employer’s 8.33% funds it; wage ceiling ₹15,000 (proposal to raise to ₹25,000).
UPS numbers: 50% / 25 years / 60% family pension / ₹10,000 minimum / AICPI-IW indexed / ~23 lakh eligible.
APY: age 18–40 • non-taxpayers • ₹1,000–₹5,000 • spouse continuation • corpus to nominee • 9 crore enrolments.
ILO 2024: global coverage 52.4%; India 48.8% cash / ~65% including in-kind; average spend 12.9% of GDP.
How was your recall?
Rating marks the question complete. “Need another pass” also adds it to your bookmarks.
References
- PAPERS-2-3-4_COMBINED.pdf — page 1298
- GeriQBank source PDF — p. 1298
Spotted an error or something out of date?Report a problem with this page